OMADEON

Resist in Multiple Forms!

Macedonia in Natural Language Search Engines! (ερωτήσεις στο Semantic Web για τη Μακεδονία) 06/05/2008

  • Greek Version: May be added later. Αν είστε ανυπόμονοι, ίσως αντέξετε προσωρινά τα… σπαστά Ελληνικά του Google Translation, ΕΔΩ)Datasets in the Linking Open Data project, as of September 2007

Today I started writing this blog-post after testing Powerset, using human questions about Macedonia (a well-known SEMANTIC dispute between Greece and another Balkan state). After all, the infamous “naming dispute” between Greece and the Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia is -to a large extent- a SEMANTIC DISPUTE.

I am a registered beta-tester of the Powerset Semantic Search Engine (www.powerset.com) , where one can ask human questions and get (more-or-less) human answers, based on Natural Language Processing (NLP) from a Knowledge-Base that uses Wikipedia.

This morning, Andreas Blumauer, an Austrian blogger working for a Semantic Web Company in Vienna, published a post titled “Natural language search – a new breakthrough?”. After reading Andreas’ post I also tested www.ask.com, another natural language search engine, open to anyone, not just beta-testers. Here are the questions and some of the results:

Question 1: What is Macedonia?

  • Answers:

  1. (answers were collected here: http://omadeon.com/nlp/macedonia.html)
  2. PowerSet search - What is macedonia

  3. http://www.ask.com/web?qsrc=2417&o=0&l=dir&q=what+is+macedonia
  4. What is Macedonia (asking www.ask.com)

Question 2: Who are the Macedonians?

Answers:

  1. (answers were collected here: http://omadeon.com/nlp/macedonians.html)Who are the Macedonians? (in PowerSet)
  2. http://www.ask.com/web?qsrc=2417&o=0&l=dir&q=who+are+the+macedoniansWho are the Macedonians? (asked in ASK.COM)

Here are some more sophisticated human answers:

Question 1: “Macedonia” can mean a “geographic region”, OR a sovereign state (F.Y.R.O.M), OR a large province of another sovereign State (Greece), OR an an ethnic identity (of Macedonian Slavs) OR another (very different) ethnic identity (of Greeks from Greek Macedonia), OR an Ancient Empire (of Alexander the Great), etc.

Question 2: “Macedonians” can mean anyone among a variety of identities: Greek Macedonians, Slav Macedonians, Albanian Macedonians, Bulgarian Macedonians, even Jewish Macedonians (and other ethnic groups that live -or have lived- in the region of Macedonia).

  • You can experiment with more natural language questions, e.g. “Who was Alexander the Great”, or “Where did Macedonians come from”, or “Who are the real Macedonians”. (After I collect more results, this post will probably be updated).

  • WARNING: This is a new search engine technology, and (although Natural Language Processing has existed for more than two decades) it can sometimes go wrong. So, expect impressive results, but also a lot of mistakes!
  • Unfortunately, the second search-engine (www.ask.com) appears to be considerably biased, in the naming dispute, in favour of Slav Macedonians. However, before condemning it, consider the possibility (almost a certainty) that the cause of this is not the fault of the search-engine itself, but the overwhelming propaganda presenting inhabitants of FYROM as the ONLY “true Macedonians”!
  • So, why is Powerset more unbiased? -Probably because it is based exclusively on ONE source (Wikipedia) where the balance between the 2 sides is better than in the whole World Wide Web (sadly for Greece).

Google search is the world's most popular search engine.

Gooogle has serious competitors, now…

PowerSet natural language search engine

www.ask.com

True Knowledge Semantic Search Engine (UK)

(click on these images to explore the new Semantic Web sites)

(video-introduction to the Semantic Web Search by True Knowledge, UK)

NOTES:

  • Chart showing the stages in the software release cycle
  • Only a few dozen results have been uploaded from Powerset. More results will be uploaded in a short while.

  • Unfortunately, the Powerset Natural Language Search Engine is only available to registered Beta-testers, at the moment. The results can’t be accessed directly in public. They are instead uploaded by hand, via ftp to my site.
  • I am also a registered tester of the “TrueKnowledge” Semantic Search Engine (based in Cambridge, UK). New posts about this will probably appear in this blog, in the next few days.

Related articles about Macedonia (automatically added by Semantic WordPress Plugin “Zemanta” ):

Related articles about the Semantic Web:

.

About these ads
 

2 Responses to “Macedonia in Natural Language Search Engines! (ερωτήσεις στο Semantic Web για τη Μακεδονία)”

  1. rhodeslesstraveled Λέει:

    they have all sorts of naming problems in greece. on one hand, we have to nations fighting over the name macedonia while on the other, we have a group of island dwellers from lesbos and a group of female homosexuals fighting over who should be called lesbians and who shouldn’t. what is in a name anyway?

    check out http://www.rhodes.com

  2. omadeon Λέει:

    @rhodeslesstraveled

    Well, you are right about “all sorts of naming problems in Greece”.

    Having lived in the UK for many years I do NOT share with the average Greek this kind of extreme sensitivity. I am only worried in case THIS naming problem (the Macedonia dispute) has serious bad side-effects on many other issues that the average “name-worrying Greek” does not even imagine. The EXTREME STUDIPITY of insisting on an irrational view like “Macedonia is (only) Greek”, is what causes the worst problem, since in this way no decent compromise can succeed, the problem will remain and get worse with time, and Greece will lose even… financial copyrights as regards the term “Macedonia”.

    As regards the other “naming problme” in Lesvos, I think this is the absolute ULTIMATE in typically Greek stupidity, and if we really look into this silly problem deeply, we will realize the silliness of all the other problems, of nationalist fanaticism in Greece.
    (In other blogs I opposed these closed-minded Lesvian fanatics).

    BTW, the island of Lesvos is not LESBOS. I.e. the problem does not exist, since people from Lesvos can be simply called “LESVIANS”, instead of “LESBIANS”!!! How come I didn’t realize this till now?
    (Oh dear! I brainwashed too, NOT to think clearly about it?) hehe :)


Υποβολή απάντησης

Εισάγετε τα παρακάτω στοιχεία ή επιλέξτε ένα εικονίδιο για να συνδεθείτε:

WordPress.com Logo

Σχολιάζετε χρησιμοποιώντας τον λογαριασμό WordPress.com. Log Out / Αλλαγή )

Twitter picture

Σχολιάζετε χρησιμοποιώντας τον λογαριασμό Twitter. Log Out / Αλλαγή )

Facebook photo

Σχολιάζετε χρησιμοποιώντας τον λογαριασμό Facebook. Log Out / Αλλαγή )

Google+ photo

Σχολιάζετε χρησιμοποιώντας τον λογαριασμό Google+. Log Out / Αλλαγή )

Σύνδεση με %s

 
Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 171 other followers