Extracts from David Graeber‘s answers in an interview:
What is Debt? – An Interview with Economic Anthropologist David Graeber
…In the past, periods dominated by virtual credit money have also been periods where there have been social protections for debtors. Once you recognize that money is just a social construct, a credit, an IOU, then first of all what is to stop people from generating it endlessly? And how do you prevent the poor from falling into debt traps and becoming effectively enslaved to the rich? That’s why you had Mesopotamian clean slates, Biblical Jubilees, Medieval laws against usury in both Christianity and Islam and so on and so forth.
Since antiquity the worst-case scenario that everyone felt would lead to total social breakdown was a major debt crisis; ordinary people would become so indebted to the top one or two percent of the population that they would start selling family members into slavery, or eventually, even themselves.
Well, what happened this time around? Instead of creating some sort of overarching institution to protect debtors, they create these grandiose, world-scale institutions like the IMF or S&P to protect creditors. They essentially declare (in defiance of all traditional economic logic) that no debtor should ever be allowed to default. Needless to say the result is catastrophic. We are experiencing something that to me, at least, looks exactly like what the ancients were most afraid of: a population of debtors skating at the edge of disaster.
And, I might add, if Aristotle were around today, I very much doubt he would think that the distinction between renting yourself or members of your family out to work and selling yourself or members of your family to work was more than a legal nicety. He’d probably conclude that most Americans were, for all intents and purposes, slaves…
PP: You mention that the IMF and S&P are institutions that are mainly geared toward extracting debts for creditors. This seems to have become the case in the European monetary union too. What do you make of the situation in Europe at the moment?
DG: Well, I think this is a prime example of why existing arrangements are clearly untenable. Obviously the ‘whole debt’ cannot be paid. But even when some French banks offered voluntary write-downs for Greece, the others insisted they would treat it as if it were a default anyway. The UK takes the even weirder position that this is true even of debts the government owes to banks that have been nationalized – that is, technically, that they owe to themselves! If that means that disabled pensioners are no longer able to use public transit or youth centers have to be closed down, well that’s simply the ‘reality of the situation,’ as they put it.
These ‘realities’ are being increasingly revealed to simply be ones of power. Clearly any pretence that markets maintain themselves, that debts always have to be honored, went by the boards in 2008. That’s one of the reasons I think you see the beginnings of a reaction in a remarkably similar form to what we saw during the heyday of the ‘Third World debt crisis’ – what got called, rather weirdly, the ‘anti-globalization movement’. This movement called for genuine democracy and actually tried to practice forms of direct, horizontal democracy. In the face of this there was the insidious alliance between financial elites and global bureaucrats (whether the IMF, World Bank, WTO, now EU, or what-have-you).
When thousands of people begin assembling in squares in Greece and Spain calling for real democracy what they are effectively saying is: “Look, in 2008 you let the cat out of the bag. If money really is just a social construct now, a promise, a set of IOUs and even trillions of debts can be made to vanish if sufficiently powerful players demand it then, if democracy is to mean anything, it means that everyone gets to weigh in on the process of how these promises are made and renegotiated.” I find this extraordinarily hopeful…
-David Graeber
[…]
Related articles
- The Creditor-Debtor Relationship: Low Level Disruption (cleardebt.co.uk)
- Debt collectors: Business great but hard as ever (seattletimes.nwsource.com)
- Debt Collection More Difficult Amid Struggling Economy (newyork.cbslocal.com)
- The Origin of Debt (midwestaholic.wordpress.com)
- Are Most Americans Debt Slaves? (ritholtz.com)
- ‘Catastrophic risk’ – Geithner warns IMF on Euro debt (politico.com)
- Economic Anthropology: David Graeber Meets the Noise Machine… (delong.typepad.com)
- An Interview With David Graeber: Debt’s History, Implications, and Critical Perspective (3quarksdaily.com)
STOPCARTEL TV-GR – live streaming video powered by Livestream http://www.livestream.com/stopcarteltvgr via @addthis
Κανονικά θα έπρεπε να αναπαράγω ΟΛΟΚΛΗΡΟ αυτό το ποστ, για ενημέρωση
http://sxoliastesxwrissynora.wordpress.com/2011/09/25/%CF%87%CE%B9%CE%BB%CE%B9%CE%AC%CE%B4%CE%B5%CF%82-%CE%BA%CF%8C%CF%83%CE%BC%CE%BF%CF%85-%CE%BE%CE%B1%CE%BD%CE%AC-%CF%83%CF%84%CE%BF-%CF%83%CF%8D%CE%BD%CF%84%CE%B1%CE%B3%CE%BC%CE%B1-%CF%84%CF%89%CF%81/
Χιλιάδες κόσμου ξανά στο Σύνταγμα, ΤΩΡΑ. Κοκτέιλ χημικών και άγριο ξύλο, λίγο μετά τις 18:00 (25-09-2011) – ΜΑΤ εναντίον Αγανακτισμένων – Βίντεο και φωτογραφίες. + Δελτίο Γιουχαισμάτων & αυγοπετάγματος.
Αυτ’ο θέλεί μετάφραση και αναδημοσιεύσει
ςς
Ναι, ξέρω… αλλά δυστυχώς ΔΕΝ ΕΙΝΑΙ το μοναδικό κείμενο που «θέλει μετάφραση και αναδημοσίευση»! 🙂
(π.χ. μόλις τελείωσα νέο βίντεο, με μεταφράσεις… από ελληνικά στα αγγλικά, διότι ακόμη μεγαλύτερη έλλειψη πληροφόρησης έχουν οι ξένοι για την Ελλάδα).
ΟΚ. Μια και σχολίασα, σημειώνω μερικά που διάβασα και βρήκα σημαντικά.
[1] Αστάθμητη μεταβλητή
http://www.thepressproject.gr/theme.php?type=blog&id=6004
[2] Αθεράπευτα ψεύτες και ανίκανοι: η περίπτωση Ευ. Βενιζέλου
http://www.aformi.gr/2011/09/%ce%b1%ce%b8%ce%b5%cf%81%ce%ac%cf%80%ce%b5%cf%85%cf%84%ce%b1-%cf%88%ce%b5%cf%8d%cf%84%ce%b5%cf%82-%ce%ba%ce%b1%ce%b9-%ce%b1%ce%bd%ce%af%ce%ba%ce%b1%ce%bd%ce%bf%ce%b9-%ce%b7-%cf%80%ce%b5%cf%81%ce%af/